v0.1 (pilot draft)

The criteria

Fourteen criteria. Two area grades. Clear evidence at every level.

How the stages work. Every measure has five stages. Stage 1 is where many providers start and stage 5 is the very best. Choose the highest stage where you can show us everything it describes. If you are between two stages, choose the lower one.

How the grades work

Each area's grade is the mean of its seven criterion scores, rounded down. It cannot exceed its data-gate score: T4 for travel and C4 for continuity. Both safeguards, T6 and C7, must score at least 3 for any certificate.

Draft eligibility and validity thresholds
LevelBoth area gradesBoth data gatesVisit dataValidity
1At least 2At least 20 months12 months
2At least 3At least 33 months12 months
3At least 4At least 46 months36 months

Draft — calibrate in pilot. Bracketed values in the descriptors are provisional. Level 3 also requires audited grades and an independent grant decision; self-assessment alone cannot qualify.

Local Rounds

T1

Neighbourhood zones

The domiciliary care provider divides its area into defined zones, each served by a stable team, and allocates new packages by zone.

Evidence: Zone map (version, date); team-to-zone list (date); allocation procedure (reference)

  1. 1No zones; visits go wherever there is capacity
  2. 2Zones drawn up; under [50]% of visits by the zone team (TK5)
  3. 3TK5 at least [70]% for 3 months
  4. 4TK5 at least [85]% for 6 months; new packages allocated by zone
  5. 5TK5 at least [95]% for 12 months; zones agreed with the council

In simple terms

Split the area you cover into small local zones. Give each zone its own regular team of carers, and place new people with the team for their zone.

  1. Stage 1: You don't have zones yet. Carers go wherever there's a gap.
  2. Stage 2: You've drawn up your zones, but fewer than [50]% of visits are done by the zone's own team.
  3. Stage 3: At least [70]% of visits are done by the zone's own team, and you've kept that up for 3 months.
  4. Stage 4: At least [85]% of visits are done by the zone's own team for 6 months, and every new person is placed with their zone's team from day one.
  5. Stage 5: At least [95]% of visits are done by the zone's own team for 12 months, and you've agreed your zones with the council.

What to show us: your zone map, a list of which carers are in which zone, and your written rule for placing new people.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

T2

Round planning

Rounds are sequenced to cut travel, with realistic travel time scheduled between every pair of visits.

Evidence: Planning method or optimisation settings; rota extract (w/c DD/MM/YYYY); TK4 report (month)

  1. 1Rounds built ad hoc; zero-travel gaps common
  2. 2Travel time added by judgement, not checked against routes
  3. 3Route-based travel time on every visit pair; TK4 under [5]%
  4. 4Route optimisation run weekly; TK4 under [2]%; exceptions reviewed
  5. 5Plans checked monthly against actual travel; TK4 under [1]%

In simple terms

Put visits in a sensible order so carers aren't criss-crossing the area, and always leave real travel time between one visit and the next.

  1. Stage 1: Rounds are put together as you go. Visits are often booked back to back with no time to travel.
  2. Stage 2: You add travel time by gut feel, but you don't check it against real routes.
  3. Stage 3: Every gap between two visits has travel time taken from a route planner. Fewer than [5]% of gaps are too short for the journey.
  4. Stage 4: You re-run your route planning every week. Fewer than [2]% of gaps are too short for the journey, and you look into each one that is.
  5. Stage 5: Every month you compare the plan with what really happened on the road. Fewer than [1]% of gaps are too short for the journey.

What to show us: how you plan rounds (or your route planner settings), one week's rota, and your monthly report on travel gaps.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

T3

Local workforce and predictable rounds

Care workers are recruited and rostered near their zone, and rotas are issued far enough ahead to plan around.

Evidence: Recruitment adverts by zone (dates); rota issue log (period); TK6 report (month)

  1. 1Workers rostered anywhere; rotas issued at short notice
  2. 2Home location considered; rotas issued [3] days ahead
  3. 3Rotas issued [7] days ahead; late changes (TK6) measured
  4. 4Recruitment targets zones; TK6 under [10]% for 6 months
  5. 5TK6 under [5]% for 12 months; worker feedback acted on

In simple terms

Recruit carers who live near the zone they work in, and give them their rota early enough to plan their lives around it.

  1. Stage 1: Carers are sent anywhere, and rotas come out at the last minute.
  2. Stage 2: You think about where a carer lives when you plan their work. Rotas go out [3] days ahead.
  3. Stage 3: Rotas go out [7] days ahead, and you count how many visits get changed late. A late change is one made in the last [7] days before the visit, unless the person asked for it.
  4. Stage 4: You recruit for specific zones. Fewer than [10]% of visits are changed late, 6 months running.
  5. Stage 5: Fewer than [5]% of visits are changed late for 12 months, and you act on what your carers tell you.

What to show us: job adverts for each zone, a log of when rotas were sent out, and your monthly late-changes report.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

T4

Travel measurement

Data gate

Travel time, driving distance and paid staff time are measured monthly from visit data, using the scheme's KPI definitions.

Evidence: KPI return TK1–TK6 (months covered); extract method and system name; data quality check (date)

  1. 1Travel not measured
  2. 2Travel estimated from samples or planned rotas
  3. 3TK1–TK3 and TK5 from actual visit data for 3 months
  4. 4TK1–TK6 for 6 months; data checks documented; monthly review
  5. 512 months complete; TK7 emissions reported; shared with commissioners quarterly

In simple terms

Measure travel properly every month, using your real visit records and not guesses. This one matters twice: your Local Rounds grade can never be higher than your stage here.

  1. Stage 1: You don't measure travel.
  2. Stage 2: You estimate travel from a sample or from planned rotas, not from what actually happened.
  3. Stage 3: For 3 months you've measured four things from real visit records: travel time compared with care time, miles driven for each hour of care, paid time compared with care time, and the share of visits done by the zone's own team.
  4. Stage 4: For 6 months you've measured all six travel figures. You've written down how you check the data, and you look at the figures every month.
  5. Stage 5: You have a full 12 months of figures, you report the emissions from travel, and you share the figures with your commissioners every quarter.

What to show us: your monthly travel figures, how you pull the data and which system it comes from, and the date of your last data check.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

T5

Travel performance

Travel per contact hour is falling against the domiciliary care provider's baseline, or is among the best in its rurality band.

Evidence: Baseline month and values; trend for the last 6–12 months; peer comparison (date)

  1. 1No baseline, or travel rising without action
  2. 2Baseline set; improvement plan agreed
  3. 3TK1 or TK2 improved [5]% on baseline for 3 months
  4. 4TK1 and TK2 improved [10]% on baseline for 6 months
  5. 5Top quartile for TK1 and TK2 in the rurality band for 12 months

In simple terms

Show that travel is really coming down compared with where you started, or that you're already among the best for an area like yours.

  1. Stage 1: You have no starting figure to compare with, or travel is going up and nothing is being done about it.
  2. Stage 2: You've recorded your starting figures (your baseline) and agreed a plan to improve.
  3. Stage 3: Either travel time or miles driven, for each hour of care, is at least [5]% better than your baseline, 3 months running.
  4. Stage 4: Both travel time and miles driven, for each hour of care, are at least [10]% better than your baseline, 6 months running.
  5. Stage 5: For 12 months you've been in the best quarter of providers working in similar areas, for both travel time and miles driven.

What to show us: your baseline month and figures, your trend over the last 6 to 12 months, and how you compare with similar providers.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

T6

Paid travel time

Safeguard

Time travelling between visits is paid as working time and checked against the National Minimum Wage; travel costs are reimbursed.

Evidence: Pay policy (version, date); NMW check for pay period (DD/MM/YYYY); mileage policy and rate (date)

  1. 1Travel time unpaid, or never checked against NMW
  2. 2Travel paid by allowance without NMW checks
  3. 3Travel paid as working time; NMW checked every pay period
  4. 4Travel paid at the normal hourly rate; mileage at a published rate
  5. 5Whole rounds paid, including waiting time between visits

In simple terms

Pay carers for the time they spend travelling between visits, check that nobody drops below the National Minimum Wage, and pay their travel costs. Shorter rounds must never mean lower pay.

Safeguard: you need at least stage 3 here to hold any FCLR level.

  1. Stage 1: Travel time isn't paid, or you've never checked pay against the National Minimum Wage.
  2. Stage 2: You pay a travel allowance, but you don't check that total pay still meets the National Minimum Wage.
  3. Stage 3: Travel between visits is paid as working time, and every pay period you check each carer's pay against the National Minimum Wage.
  4. Stage 4: Travel time is paid at the carer's normal hourly rate, and mileage is paid at a rate you publish.
  5. Stage 5: You pay carers for the whole round, including time spent waiting between visits.

What to show us: your pay policy, your minimum wage check for a recent pay period, and your mileage policy and rate.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

T7

Commissioning and costed rounds

The domiciliary care provider works with commissioners and other providers to align zones, swap packages and price whole rounds that cover the cost of care.

Evidence: Council correspondence (dates); package swap log (period); cost of care model (version, date)

  1. 1No contact with commissioners on geography or costs
  2. 2Packages mapped against council areas; zoning raised with the council
  3. 3Costed whole-round model; zone alignment proposed in writing
  4. 4Package swaps done with other providers; costed neighbourhood proposal submitted
  5. 5Working under a neighbourhood or round-based contract, or proposal accepted by the council

In simple terms

Work with the council and other providers so each neighbourhood is served by fewer providers, and price whole rounds so the money covers the real cost of care.

  1. Stage 1: You haven't spoken to the council (your commissioners) about areas or costs.
  2. Stage 2: You've mapped the people you support against council areas, and you've raised zoning with the council.
  3. Stage 3: You've worked out what a whole round really costs, and you've proposed in writing how your zones could line up with the council's.
  4. Stage 4: You've swapped care packages with other providers to tidy up rounds, always with the person's agreement, and you've sent the council a costed plan for a neighbourhood.
  5. Stage 5: You're working under a neighbourhood or round-based contract, or the council has accepted your proposal.

What to show us: letters or emails with the council, your log of package swaps, and your cost of care workings.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

Familiar Carers

C1

Named core teams

Every person has a named core team, sized to their package (guide: [3–4] workers for up to [14] visits a week), recorded in the rostering system and shared with the person.

Evidence: Core team policy (version, date); rostering screen showing the core-team field; sample of [10] care plans naming the team (dates)

  1. 1No core teams; any available worker is sent
  2. 2Core teams named for some people, outside the rostering system
  3. 3Every person has a core team in the rostering system, sized to the package
  4. 4Core teams reviewed at each care review; core-team churn measured
  5. 5Core teams stable for 12 months, formed with people's and workers' views

In simple terms

Give every person a small, named team of carers they'll get to know. As a guide, that's [3–4] carers for someone having up to [14] visits a week. Record the team in your rostering system and tell the person who is in it.

  1. Stage 1: There are no core teams. Whoever is free gets sent.
  2. Stage 2: Some people have a named team, but it's kept on paper or in a spreadsheet, not in your rostering system.
  3. Stage 3: Everyone has a core team recorded in your rostering system, and each team is the right size for the number of visits.
  4. Stage 4: You check each person's core team at every care review, and you measure how often team members change.
  5. Stage 5: Core teams have stayed the same for 12 months, and you shaped them by asking the people you support and your carers.

What to show us: your core team policy, a screenshot of the core team field in your rostering system, and [10] care plans that name the team.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

C2

Introductions and notice

People know who is coming, and no new worker arrives as a stranger.

Evidence: Introduction procedure (version, date); CK5 and CK6 reports (month); sample rota notifications (dates)

  1. 1People not told who is coming; new workers arrive unannounced
  2. 2People told on request; introductions informal
  3. 3Rota shared [7] days ahead with everyone; CK5 at least [80]%
  4. 4CK5 and CK6 at least [90]% for 6 months; same-day changes notified before the visit
  5. 5CK5 and CK6 at least [95]% for 12 months; people choose how they get notice

In simple terms

People should always know who is coming, and a new carer should never turn up as a stranger.

  1. Stage 1: People aren't told who is coming, and new carers turn up without warning.
  2. Stage 2: People are told who is coming if they ask. Introductions happen sometimes, but there's no set way of doing them.
  3. Stage 3: Everyone gets their rota [7] days ahead. At least [80]% of visits by a carer who is new to the person happen after a proper introduction.
  4. Stage 4: For 6 months, at least [90]% of new carers were introduced first and at least [90]% of visits had a week's notice of who was coming. If something changes on the day, you tell the person before the visit.
  5. Stage 5: For 12 months, at least [95]% of new carers were introduced first and at least [95]% of visits had a week's notice. People choose how they're told: a call, a text, a letter or an app.

What to show us: your introductions procedure, your monthly figures for introductions and notice, and some examples of rotas you sent to people.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

C3

Absence cover

Sickness, leave and vacancies are covered from the core team or zone team first.

Evidence: Cover procedure (version, date); cover log showing source of cover (period); CK4 trend (months)

  1. 1Cover taken from anywhere; source not recorded
  2. 2Procedure prefers the core team; not measured
  3. 3Cover source recorded; most cover from the core or zone team
  4. 4Planned leave covered from the core team in [90]% of cases; float workers attached to zones
  5. 5CK4 under [5]% of visits for 12 months, holiday periods included

In simple terms

When a carer is off sick, on holiday or has left, cover the visit with someone the person already knows: their core team first, then the zone team.

  1. Stage 1: Cover comes from whoever is free, and you don't record who covered.
  2. Stage 2: Your procedure says to use the core team first, but you don't measure whether that happens.
  3. Stage 3: You record who covers each visit, and most cover comes from the person's core team or zone team.
  4. Stage 4: Planned leave is covered by the core team [90]% of the time, and your float (relief) carers each belong to a zone.
  5. Stage 5: For 12 months, holiday periods included, fewer than [5]% of visits were made by a carer who was new to the person.

What to show us: your cover procedure, your cover log showing who covered, and your trend for visits by new faces.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

C4

Continuity measurement

Data gate

Continuity is measured monthly per person from visit data, by package band, using the scheme's KPI definitions.

Evidence: KPI return CK1–CK7 (months covered); extract method and system name; data quality check (date)

  1. 1Continuity not measured
  2. 2Measured by sample or manual counts
  3. 3CK1–CK4 from actual visit data for 3 months, by package band
  4. 4CK1–CK7 for 6 months; monthly review; low-continuity people flagged for action
  5. 512 months complete; reviewed at every care review; shared with commissioners quarterly

In simple terms

Measure every month, for each person, how often they see the same carers, using your real visit records. This one matters twice: your Familiar Carers grade can never be higher than your stage here.

  1. Stage 1: You don't measure continuity.
  2. Stage 2: You measure it now and then, from a sample or by counting by hand.
  3. Stage 3: For 3 months you've measured four things from real visit records, grouped by how many visits a week people have: visits done by the core team, how many different carers each person sees, how much each person's visits stay with the same few carers, and visits by new faces.
  4. Stage 4: For 6 months you've measured all seven continuity figures. You look at them every month, and you flag anyone who is seeing too many different carers so you can put it right.
  5. Stage 5: You have a full 12 months of figures, you look at them at every care review, and you share them with your commissioners every quarter.

What to show us: your monthly continuity figures, how you pull the data and which system it comes from, and the date of your last data check.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

C5

Continuity performance

Continuity is improving against the domiciliary care provider's baseline, or is among the best in its rurality band.

Evidence: Baseline month and values; trend for the last 6–12 months; peer comparison (date)

  1. 1No baseline, or continuity falling without action
  2. 2Baseline set; improvement plan agreed
  3. 3CK1 up [5] percentage points on baseline, or at least [70]%, for 3 months
  4. 4CK1 up [10] points or at least [80]%, with CK3 rising, for 6 months
  5. 5Top quartile for CK1 and CK3 in the rurality band for 12 months

In simple terms

Show that people are seeing their regular carers more often than when you started, or that you're already among the best for an area like yours.

  1. Stage 1: You have no starting figure to compare with, or continuity is getting worse and nothing is being done about it.
  2. Stage 2: You've recorded your starting figures (your baseline) and agreed a plan to improve.
  3. Stage 3: For 3 months, the share of visits done by people's core teams is up [5] percentage points on your baseline, or is at least [70]%.
  4. Stage 4: For 6 months, the share of visits done by core teams is up [10] points on your baseline or is at least [80]%, and people's visits are staying more and more with the same few carers.
  5. Stage 5: For 12 months you've been in the best quarter of providers working in similar areas, both for core team visits and for keeping visits with the same few carers.

What to show us: your baseline month and figures, your trend over the last 6 to 12 months, and how you compare with similar providers.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

C6

Noticing and escalating change

Workers record changes in health or wellbeing with a structured tool and escalate them to the right professional the same day.

Evidence: Tool name and version; training records (dates); sample of [10] escalations with outcomes (dates); GP or neighbourhood team contacts per zone

  1. 1No structured recording of change
  2. 2Changes noted in free-text visit notes only
  3. 3Structured tool in use; workers trained; escalation route written down
  4. 4Escalations audited monthly; named GP or neighbourhood contacts in each zone
  5. 5Escalation outcomes tracked and learning shared with neighbourhood partners

In simple terms

Carers who know someone well are the first to spot when something isn't right. Give them a simple, set way to record it and pass it to the right professional the same day.

  1. Stage 1: There's no set way to record a change in someone's health or wellbeing.
  2. Stage 2: Changes get written in ordinary visit notes, where they can be missed.
  3. Stage 3: Carers use a proper checklist-style tool, they've been trained to use it, and it's written down who to tell and how.
  4. Stage 4: Every month you check that concerns were passed on properly, and each zone has named contacts at the GP surgery or neighbourhood team.
  5. Stage 5: You track what happened after each concern was raised, and you share what you learn with local health and care partners.

What to show us: the tool you use, your training records, [10] examples of concerns raised and what happened next, and your GP or neighbourhood contacts for each zone.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.

C7

Choice and voice

Safeguard

Preferences about who provides care are recorded and honoured; people can ask to change worker without penalty; zoning never overrides choice.

Evidence: Sample of preferences in care plans (dates); change-of-worker request log (period); CK7 survey results (date)

  1. 1Preferences not recorded; change requests refused or not logged
  2. 2Preferences in some care plans; requests handled informally
  3. 3Preferences recorded for everyone; requests answered within [5] working days; CK7 survey run
  4. 4CK7 run twice a year with action plans; preference matching tracked
  5. 5People and families help shape core teams; CK7 results published on the register

In simple terms

People choose who cares for them. Record what they prefer, stick to it, and let them ask for a different carer without any comeback. Your zones must never override a person's choice.

Safeguard: you need at least stage 3 here to hold any FCLR level.

  1. Stage 1: Preferences aren't recorded, and requests to change carer are refused or not written down.
  2. Stage 2: Preferences are in some care plans, and requests to change carer are dealt with informally.
  3. Stage 3: Everyone's preferences are recorded, requests to change carer get an answer within [5] working days, and you've run the FCLR survey (two short questions: do you usually know who is coming, and do you mostly see carers you know).
  4. Stage 4: You run the survey twice a year and act on the results, and you keep track of how well you match people with the carers they prefer.
  5. Stage 5: People and their families help decide who is in their core team, and your survey results are published on the FCLR register.

What to show us: examples of preferences in care plans, your log of requests to change carer, and your survey results.

This is a plain-English guide. The official wording is what we assess against.